Ageing Reframed

Interview · Aged care

Capital asymmetry in aged care: are you building the right advantage?

Professor Rick Watson studies how organisations build advantages that competitors find hard to copy. I asked him what his capital asymmetry framework means for aged care providers in Australia. Afterwards, he ran a session with one provider’s team.

Piet Mondrian's 1921 painting: a large red square at the top left, yellow and white blocks to its right, and black, grey and blue blocks below, all divided by thick black lines.
Reading Professor Watson’s paper, I was reminded of a Mondrian grid: ordered lines, unequal blocks, and balance achieved through imbalance.Piet Mondrian, Composition with Large Red Plane, Yellow, Black, Grey and Blue, 1921. Kunstmuseum Den Haag.

In conversation

Rick Watson Professor Rick Watson

Regents Professor, University of Georgia

Honorary Professor, University of Melbourne and QUT

George Gouzounis

Interview by
George Gouzounis, Ageing Reframed

Aged care in Australia is consolidating. Larger providers are buying smaller ones, keeping staff is hard, and reputation affects how many people choose a provider. Most providers feel the competition. Fewer have a clear way of deciding where to build an advantage that others can’t easily copy.

Capital asymmetry is a framework developed by Professor Rick Watson. In a 2025 paper in Business Horizons, he and Hani Safadi apply it to more than a century of competition in the car industry, from Ford to BYD.

The idea is that an organisation builds a lasting advantage by investing in a type of capital, or a mix of types, in a way competitors can’t easily match. There are six types: economic, human, natural, organisational, social and symbolic.

For an aged care provider, this comes down to choosing where to invest. It could be the workforce (human capital), systems and processes (organisational capital), or a reputation for good care in particular communities (symbolic capital).

The full paper

Capital asymmetry: A lens for strategic analysis

Richard T. Watson and Hani Safadi. Business Horizons, 2025. Journal pre-proof, PDF, 29 pages.

Journal page

Six types of capital

Every organisation puts some resources aside now to create value later. When a provider pays for staff to gain a qualification, it adds to its human capital, expecting better decisions and higher productivity in return. Professor Watson calls the mix of these investments an organisation’s capital creation recipe. Every organisation has one, even if it has never been written down.

The framework names six types of capital. They apply in any industry.

The six types of capital, what each one is, and what an advantage in each looks like
CapitalWhat it isWhat an advantage looks like
EconomicFinancial, physical and manufactured resources, and revenue streamsControl of assets that give exceptional economic scale or scope
HumanThe skills, knowledge and abilities of a workforceA highly talented, skilled and motivated workforce
NaturalRights to use or extract natural resources, such as farming and miningVery fertile land in a suitable climate, or an accessible, high-yielding mineral deposit
OrganisationalInstitutional knowledge and codified experience (software and databases), routines, patents, manuals and structuresPatents, copyrights or trademarks that are hard to imitate, or exclusive data sets and proprietary algorithms
SocialAn organisation’s ability to benefit from its social connectionsInfluential connections that give exclusive access to vital capital, or exceptionally loyal customers
SymbolicAn organisation’s reputation, image, brands and ranking within its industryA highly preferred brand, or a reputation for quality, honesty and customer service

Adapted from Table 1 in Watson and Safadi (2025).

Capital asymmetry is when an organisation builds a set of capital that fits together and that competitors can’t easily copy. In the paper’s car industry cases, the company that did this first gained market share that held until a competitor found a new kind of asymmetry.

Toyota is one example. Lifetime employment and steady investment in training (human capital) let it make high-quality cars (economic capital) at competitive prices for decades. Chinese electric vehicle makers are now challenging it with different asymmetries, built on very large research and development teams and vertical integration.

Rick Watson speaking to a seated group, with a slide behind him titled Making Capital Out of Chaos: Social Media Strategy.
Professor Watson running a workshop at Swarovski’s headquarters near Innsbruck, Austria.

I asked Professor Watson eight questions about how the framework applies to aged care. His answers have been lightly edited.

What should an aged care provider focus on?

Aged care organisations, like any other business, need to create capital to remain viable. Aged care’s capital creation recipe is quite complex. My assessment is that its main focus should be human capital: aged care recipients, their families and loved ones, and staff.

First, make sure clients receive quality care and medical attention, and that they engage socially. Second, keep easing the anxiety of clients’ families by reassuring them that their expectations of care are being met. Third, make sure staff are appropriately trained, supported, rewarded and motivated.

Managing these three dimensions of human capital well is central to creating a capital asymmetry.

How do systems and reputation affect a provider’s results?

Organisational capital determines staff productivity and care quality. Processes should be designed to keep staff’s secondary responsibilities, such as record-keeping, to a minimum, so there is more time for direct care. Timely data are critical for care quality, especially for a population that often has several health problems at once.

Providers that get the basics right, with caring staff and efficient processes, will build social capital, which attracts clients directly or through their families and friends. Symbolic capital comes from a reputation for exceptional care, which can support higher fees.

“In brief, social capital gets customers, and symbolic capital gets a price premium.”

Rick Watson

Where do parks and gardens come in?

There is considerable evidence that access to parks and green space (natural capital) improves mental and physical health. I’m fortunate to live next to a large park in Melbourne, and I get some of my best ideas on my daily walk.

Minneapolis is one of the healthiest cities in the US, and its many easily reached parks are identified as a key factor. My family lived there for three years, where the average January maximum is −5°C. Our children had to go outside at recess unless there was a blizzard. Minnesotans are brought up to enjoy healthy outdoor recreation.

For aged care facilities, being close to good green space, or being able to create gardens on site, can set a provider apart for residents and their families.

Is aged care at a turning point?

Yes, I believe aged care is at a transition point. The next wave of competitive advantage will likely come from organisational capital, specifically from how providers use robots and AI to improve care quality and efficiency.

We are currently researching how robots and AI can improve care. Advances in sensing technology will enable robots to measure a care recipient’s status. For example, a robot with an artificial nose can assess a person’s breath to detect chemicals that indicate health problems. It can also record speech and chronicle changes in vital signs and behaviour. Essentially, robots will collect data, and AI will analyse it to detect changes in a client’s health and behaviour.

Aged care facilities that lead in learning how to implement robots and AI can create an organisational asymmetry. That could help them recruit and keep staff, and attract a price premium.

How do busy providers make time to think about this?

Immediate problems dominate daily decision-making and determine short-term success. Thinking strategically should also be a daily practice, but it needs about 10 to 15 minutes of undistracted time. I suggest a walk around the neighbourhood or a nearby park, without your phone and among trees. If you must take a phone, use it only to capture your thoughts about the future of your business.

“Capital, in essence, is forgoing current consumption in anticipation of future gains.”

Rick Watson

The first farmers, instead of eating all their grain, put some aside to sow for next year’s crop. Leaders must set aside time to think about the future. Thinking enhances your human capital.

How should a provider use the asymmetry analysis grid?

An asymmetry analysis compares a firm with its major competitors across the different types of capital. It’s a prerequisite for identifying a strategy to achieve a capital asymmetry, or to overcome an asymmetry disadvantage.

I recommend that the top management team does the analysis together, with the help of a facilitator. It’s an opportunity to align the team’s understanding of the organisation’s capital creation recipe and agree on a shared direction for the future.

A sample capital asymmetry analysis grid

Each row is a type of capital, rated from low to high. Green marks where the organisation is now, red marks a major competitor, and yellow marks where the organisation wants to be.

Sample capital asymmetry analysis grid. Positions for a competitor, the organisation now, and the organisation’s goal on each type of capital, from low to high.
CapitalLowLow to mediumMediumMedium to highHigh
Economic
Human
Natural
Organisational
Social
Symbolic
Show the grid as text
CapitalCompetitorCurrentGoal
EconomicLowLowLow
HumanLow to mediumLowMedium
NaturalLowLow to mediumLow to medium
OrganisationalLow to mediumLow to mediumMedium to high
SocialLow to mediumLow to mediumMedium
SymbolicMediumLow to mediumMedium
The paper suggests doing one grid for each major competitor, then agreeing on one set of goals as a team. It also notes that building an asymmetry takes significant investment, so a row of yellow dots on the far right is rarely realistic. Grid design by Richard T. Watson, adapted from Figure 5 in Watson and Safadi (2025).

Free download

Blank capital asymmetry analysis grid

Designed by Richard T. Watson and shared under a Creative Commons BY-SA licence. One A4 page, PDF.

How can a provider catch up with bigger competitors?

“If you’re behind better-resourced competitors, trying to copy their asymmetry won’t work.”

Rick Watson

Our research indicates that a firm’s capital asymmetry persists until an innovative capital creation model emerges, as we’re seeing with BYD and other Chinese manufacturers disrupting traditional car companies.

I recommend that aged care providers do an asymmetry analysis every year to track their main competitors, and look for chances to gradually close gaps or find gaps they can fill. At the same time, they should scan for innovations that could set them apart.

Our recent analysis suggests that knowledge capital asymmetries are the next stage. These are created by combining experts (human capital) with data and software (organisational capital), essentially turning workforce expertise into scalable, data-driven systems.

What happens to providers who don’t plan for this?

As Lewis Carroll wrote in Through the Looking-Glass, the Red Queen had to keep running to stay in the same place. Survival requires constant adaptation to keep pace with competitors who are always evolving. Organisations that don’t plan for a different future will slip behind until they lose their place in the industry. In a consolidating sector like aged care, that means acquisition or exit.

Alice and the Red Queen running at full speed over grass, Alice's hair streaming behind her and the Queen's cloak flying.
Alice and the Red Queen, drawn by John Tenniel for the first edition of Through the Looking-Glass, 1872. The colour was added later.

Case study: Access Sydney Community Transport

After this interview, Access Sydney Community Transport asked Professor Watson to run a planning session with its aged care team. Access Sydney’s CEO, Michelle Newman, has let us share what came out of it.

Access Sydney is a not-for-profit that has provided door-to-door transport and social connection for more than 30 years. It serves older people, people with disability and others who find it hard to get around, across nine Sydney local government areas. Most of its funding comes from the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing, Transport for NSW and NSW Health, with an annual City of Sydney grant and one small commercial operation.

Eight people took part. The aim was to work out where to invest so the organisation can better achieve its mission.

Naming the challenges. Each person wrote down the organisation’s key challenges, one per sheet of paper. Everyone then had eight sticky dots to vote with, and anything with fewer than two votes was set aside. The group mapped how the remaining challenges connect, with growth and sustainability at the centre. Two drew the most votes: workforce, covering retention, skills, recruitment and future needs (14 votes), and manual systems and processes (12 votes).

Rating the capital. The team then rated five of the six types of capital, one at a time, on a five-point scale. Natural capital wasn’t in scope for a transport service.

Social and human capital rated highest, economic capital lowest

Average rating from the eight people in the session. 1 is well short, 5 is more than enough, and 3 is about right for the organisation’s mission and funding.

Show the figures
CapitalAverage rating
Social3.81
Human3.38
Symbolic2.88
Organisational1.75
Economic1.00
Source: Professor Watson’s analysis of the session, shared with Access Sydney’s permission.

Social capital (3.81) and human capital (3.38) rated highest. Economic capital (1.00) and organisational capital (1.75) rated lowest. Everyone in the room rated economic capital 1 out of 5.

Systems came up in both parts of the session, as the second-biggest challenge and the second-lowest rating. People came up as both a strength and a worry. Human capital rated above about right, and workforce drew the most votes as a challenge.

This was one session with one team. Professor Watson suggests repeating the analysis each year to see how the picture changes.

About Professor Watson

Rick Watson

Professor Rick Watson

Regents Professor, University of Georgia

Rick is Regents Professor and J. Rex Fuqua Distinguished Chair for Internet Strategy Emeritus at the University of Georgia, and a former President of the Association for Information Systems, which gave him its highest award, the LEO. For about ten years he was Research Director for the Advanced Practices Council of the Society for Information Management, and he has been a visiting researcher at the Research Institutes of Sweden (RISE). He holds honorary professorships at the University of Melbourne and Queensland University of Technology, is a Schöller Senior Fellow at the University of Erlangen-Nürnberg, and received an honorary doctorate from the University of Liechtenstein in 2021.

He has published more than 200 journal articles and written or edited more than 30 books, on topics including electronic commerce, data management and energy informatics. His most recent books are Capital, Systems, and Objects and Causal Knowledge Analytics. He has given more than 350 invited talks in more than 30 countries. He studied at the University of Western Australia, Monash University and the University of Minnesota, and lives in Melbourne.

About the paper

Richard T. Watson and Hani Safadi, “Capital asymmetry: A lens for strategic analysis”, Business Horizons, 2025. The paper sets out the six types of capital, the car industry cases from Ford to BYD, and a four-phase approach to building capital asymmetry into strategy.